What do you get when you put Dustin Hoffman and Meryl Streep in the same scene: Pure awesomeness!
Originally posted by Carlos Baena
Wednesday, May 30, 2012
Monday, May 21, 2012
3ds Max vs Maya: Part 2, the Timeline
I apologize for the delay in this post but I've been very busy at work and at home right now. I'll do my best to push the third post as fast as I can.
OK, next in line: The Timeline!
The Timeline, or TimeSlider, is the numbered bar at the bottom of the screen in 3dsMax and Maya. Lucky us, they both place in the same place!
They both behave the same way, but your workflow can change drastically from one to the other. I learned 3D in 3dsMax and when I switched to Maya, it was one of the hardest things to get use to. It was not because scrolling the timeline was different or anything like that, it was because handling the keys in the timeline is way different.
You'll what I'm talking about... On to the review!
The way I see it, in 3dsMax the cursor is divided in two: The cursor itself and the Cursor Bar (or more appropriately called "Timeline Bar").
Maya has a more simple approach, in the sense that there is no bar, you can drag the cursor itself in order to go through the timeline.
As I said, the principle is the same: Click and drag to move through the timeline. However, the means of doing it is different. In 3dsMax, in order to move the cursor you have to drag the bar instead. The cool thing about the bar though is that it doesn't change it's size no matter the range of the timeline, whether in Maya, the cursor will reduce its size in order to fit the range, which becomes a bit of a pain when working with big ranges (animations of 400+ frames).
Another thing is that the bar displays your position and the number of frames you have in the timeline, while in Maya you have a value beside the timeline which displays your current frame, but you don't have the number of frames of the timeline.
So Maya might have a simpler way to manage the timeline, but I believe 3dsMax is more friendly and easier to work with.
The difference is basically the way you switch between jumping through frames or jumping through keys. In Maya, to switch between these modes, you just have to add the ALT key to the hotkeys, so if you want to jump to the next frame, just press "Alt + .".
3dsMax has a special key to switch between the two modes, its called "KeyMode Toggle". It's located under the playback controls (see image).
What this button does is enables the "," and "." to jump through keys instead of frames. So this is the equivalent of using the Alt key in Maya.
Another thing to note is that clicking on the arrow buttons in the timeline bar in 3dsMax will have the same effect as using the "," and "." hotkeys, with the addition that whenever you click on them, the mouse pointer will move too, so you don't have to follow the bar when it jumps. Do it to see what I mean...
Maya is different. The keys displayed in the timeline are called "Ticks" and they're only one color: Red. There is not much to say about it other than you can change the width of the ticks in the settings, in case you find them too thin. The tick represents a key in that frame, all translations and/or attributes.
Note: I have realized that there are some attributes that are not displayed in the timeline, like the camera Focal Length for example. If someone knows how to display these attributes, leave your tip in the comments ;)
Now, there is a small difference in the displaying of the keys that not everyone will notice: The position of the keys in the timeline. In 3ds Max, when you place the timeline cursor over a frame, the cursor covers the entire key. In Maya however, you can see that the key tick is located beside the cursor. This might be a bit confusing when first switching from one program to the other, but no worries, they both work the same way.
Note: It's worth to mention that in 3ds Max, there is a way to display the timeline in a Frame:Ticks way. You just have to configure the display options in the Time Configuration window.
- CTRL + ALT + Left-Click: Change the start frame
- CTRL + ALT + Right-Click: Change the end frame
- CTRL + ALT + Middle-Click: Move the whole range forward or backwards (this one does not alter the size of the timeline, but the position in time of the whole range)
You can also do it in the Time Configuration window and enter the exact values you want.
In Maya it's a bit easier. You have input boxes where you can type the values you want for the start and end of either the timeline or the playback range. You also have a bar between these boxes that work just for playback, so you can easily adjust the playback range.
First Copy Keys.
In Maya, there are two ways to copy one key to another frame. You can move the cursor over the frame you want to copy, RIGHT-click and select "Copy"; then move to the frame you want to paste the key and RIGHT-click to select "Paste". The other way is to put the timeline cursor on the frame you want to copy, then hover your mouse pointer over the frame in the timeline where you want to paste the key and MIDDLE-click. You'll notice that the timeline cursor moved but the animation stayed still. You can now add a key by pressing "s" (default hotkey) to add a key and keep that pose.
In 3ds Max, there are also two ways to copy a key: The first method is to simply select the key you want to copy (in the timeline) and SHIFT-Drag the key to the frame you want that key. The second method is to move the timeline cursor to the key you want to copy, then RIGHT-Click drag the timeline bar to the frame you want to copy the key to. Once you release the mouse button, a pop-up window will appear asking you which translate you want to key. Press OK and you're done.
As you can see, all methods are slightly similar, which make it easy to confuse with one another when switching programs. The same thing happens for moving keys. In 3ds Max, just select the key and move it wherever you want. In Maya, to select a key you first have to SHIFT-Left Click on the key to selected. The key will turn red. Then, you can move it.
To delete a key in 3ds Max, select the key and press the Delete key in your keyboard. In Maya, put the timeline cursor over the key you want to delete, RIGHT-Click to open the menu and select Delete.
- In Maya, changes in the timeline are undoable. In other words, whenever you scrub the timeline using hotkeys or by using the timeline cursor, you can undo the action. I have a post that explains a way to avoid adding those actions into the undo queue.
- In 3ds Max, adding a key in the middle of your timeline (let's say frame 35) will automatically add a key in frame 0. You can stop this behavior by turning off that feature in the Preferences\Animation menu, under the "Auto key On" option.
So, I have to say every time I work in Maya there are moments that miss the 3ds Max timeslider. I believe it's easier to work with, and the fact that you can filter what translation keys to show, plus the simplicity to copy, move or delete keys, places it on top of Maya's timeline.
Next (and last topic) in the review: Everything else! A list of difference that I believe is worth mentioning between these two programs... Stay tuned! :P
OK, next in line: The Timeline!
The Timeline, or TimeSlider, is the numbered bar at the bottom of the screen in 3dsMax and Maya. Lucky us, they both place in the same place!
 |
| 3ds Max and Maya timelines |
They both behave the same way, but your workflow can change drastically from one to the other. I learned 3D in 3dsMax and when I switched to Maya, it was one of the hardest things to get use to. It was not because scrolling the timeline was different or anything like that, it was because handling the keys in the timeline is way different.
You'll what I'm talking about... On to the review!
Scrolling
The way you scroll the timeline does not change between both programs. You still have to grab the timeline cursor and drag it through the timeline to watch your animation. It's the cursor itself that changes.The way I see it, in 3dsMax the cursor is divided in two: The cursor itself and the Cursor Bar (or more appropriately called "Timeline Bar").
 |
| Timeline Bar and its cursor |
Maya has a more simple approach, in the sense that there is no bar, you can drag the cursor itself in order to go through the timeline.
 |
| Maya timeline cursor |
As I said, the principle is the same: Click and drag to move through the timeline. However, the means of doing it is different. In 3dsMax, in order to move the cursor you have to drag the bar instead. The cool thing about the bar though is that it doesn't change it's size no matter the range of the timeline, whether in Maya, the cursor will reduce its size in order to fit the range, which becomes a bit of a pain when working with big ranges (animations of 400+ frames).
Another thing is that the bar displays your position and the number of frames you have in the timeline, while in Maya you have a value beside the timeline which displays your current frame, but you don't have the number of frames of the timeline.
So Maya might have a simpler way to manage the timeline, but I believe 3dsMax is more friendly and easier to work with.
Navigating through the timeline using hotkeys
Both programs use the same hotkeys to navigate through the timeline: "," to step backwards and "." to move forward. The default setting in both programs in different though. In Maya, you jump through keys while in 3dsMax by default you jump through frames.The difference is basically the way you switch between jumping through frames or jumping through keys. In Maya, to switch between these modes, you just have to add the ALT key to the hotkeys, so if you want to jump to the next frame, just press "Alt + .".
3dsMax has a special key to switch between the two modes, its called "KeyMode Toggle". It's located under the playback controls (see image).
 |
| KeyMode Toggle |
What this button does is enables the "," and "." to jump through keys instead of frames. So this is the equivalent of using the Alt key in Maya.
Another thing to note is that clicking on the arrow buttons in the timeline bar in 3dsMax will have the same effect as using the "," and "." hotkeys, with the addition that whenever you click on them, the mouse pointer will move too, so you don't have to follow the bar when it jumps. Do it to see what I mean...
In this feature there is no clear winner but I do prefer the 3dsMax way. Personal opinion.
Displaying keys
This feature is another one where both programs differ a lot. In 3ds Max, every key in the timeline has different colors: Red (position), Green (rotation), Blue (scale), Black (for modifiers), etc. By filtering the type of key, you can work with one transform type at a time, without the need of the Dope Sheet or the Curve Editor. |
| Displaying keys in 3ds Max |
Maya is different. The keys displayed in the timeline are called "Ticks" and they're only one color: Red. There is not much to say about it other than you can change the width of the ticks in the settings, in case you find them too thin. The tick represents a key in that frame, all translations and/or attributes.
 |
| Displaying keys or "ticks" in Maya |
Note: I have realized that there are some attributes that are not displayed in the timeline, like the camera Focal Length for example. If someone knows how to display these attributes, leave your tip in the comments ;)
Now, there is a small difference in the displaying of the keys that not everyone will notice: The position of the keys in the timeline. In 3ds Max, when you place the timeline cursor over a frame, the cursor covers the entire key. In Maya however, you can see that the key tick is located beside the cursor. This might be a bit confusing when first switching from one program to the other, but no worries, they both work the same way.
Note: It's worth to mention that in 3ds Max, there is a way to display the timeline in a Frame:Ticks way. You just have to configure the display options in the Time Configuration window.
Changing timeline range
If you want to change the size of your timeline in 3ds Max, the easiest way to do it is to use the following combinations while your mouse pointer is over the timeline:- CTRL + ALT + Left-Click: Change the start frame
- CTRL + ALT + Right-Click: Change the end frame
- CTRL + ALT + Middle-Click: Move the whole range forward or backwards (this one does not alter the size of the timeline, but the position in time of the whole range)
You can also do it in the Time Configuration window and enter the exact values you want.
In Maya it's a bit easier. You have input boxes where you can type the values you want for the start and end of either the timeline or the playback range. You also have a bar between these boxes that work just for playback, so you can easily adjust the playback range.
 |
| Timeline and Playback ranges in Maya |
Keys management
The way you copy, delete or move keys within the timeline greatly affects your workflow, and as everything else in the timeline, there are some differences on how these two programs handle this feature.First Copy Keys.
In Maya, there are two ways to copy one key to another frame. You can move the cursor over the frame you want to copy, RIGHT-click and select "Copy"; then move to the frame you want to paste the key and RIGHT-click to select "Paste". The other way is to put the timeline cursor on the frame you want to copy, then hover your mouse pointer over the frame in the timeline where you want to paste the key and MIDDLE-click. You'll notice that the timeline cursor moved but the animation stayed still. You can now add a key by pressing "s" (default hotkey) to add a key and keep that pose.
In 3ds Max, there are also two ways to copy a key: The first method is to simply select the key you want to copy (in the timeline) and SHIFT-Drag the key to the frame you want that key. The second method is to move the timeline cursor to the key you want to copy, then RIGHT-Click drag the timeline bar to the frame you want to copy the key to. Once you release the mouse button, a pop-up window will appear asking you which translate you want to key. Press OK and you're done.
As you can see, all methods are slightly similar, which make it easy to confuse with one another when switching programs. The same thing happens for moving keys. In 3ds Max, just select the key and move it wherever you want. In Maya, to select a key you first have to SHIFT-Left Click on the key to selected. The key will turn red. Then, you can move it.
To delete a key in 3ds Max, select the key and press the Delete key in your keyboard. In Maya, put the timeline cursor over the key you want to delete, RIGHT-Click to open the menu and select Delete.
Additional Notes
These are some things that is worth to mention but that do not fall into any of the topics I've just mentioned:- In Maya, changes in the timeline are undoable. In other words, whenever you scrub the timeline using hotkeys or by using the timeline cursor, you can undo the action. I have a post that explains a way to avoid adding those actions into the undo queue.
- In 3ds Max, adding a key in the middle of your timeline (let's say frame 35) will automatically add a key in frame 0. You can stop this behavior by turning off that feature in the Preferences\Animation menu, under the "Auto key On" option.
So, I have to say every time I work in Maya there are moments that miss the 3ds Max timeslider. I believe it's easier to work with, and the fact that you can filter what translation keys to show, plus the simplicity to copy, move or delete keys, places it on top of Maya's timeline.
Next (and last topic) in the review: Everything else! A list of difference that I believe is worth mentioning between these two programs... Stay tuned! :P